Main Menu McGoughLawP.C., L.L.O.
Contact Our Firm:
After Hours/Emergency:
  • Nebraska’s Go-To Sex Crimes Defense Firm
  • Nebraska’s Go-To Drug Crimes Defense Firm
  • Nebraska’s Go-To Criminal Defense Firm

Police cannot draw blood without consent

One of the news stories to capture national attention this month took place in Salt Lake City, where police arrested a nurse for refusing a blood draw from an unconscious patient. The nurse was following hospital rules to protect patient privacy. The detective on the scene arrested her for obstruction.

In addition to the hospital’s rules, the United States Supreme Court made a similar ruling last year regarding consent for blood draws. In short, it says that a blood draw is intrusive of personal rights in a way that an alcohol breath test is not.

Police need consent to collect a sample. In Salt Lake City, there was no warrant, the patient was not a suspect in a crime and, because the patient was unconscious, there was no way to get consent.

Search and seizure, consent and personal property

Search and seizure is central to the Bill of Rights, granting personal freedoms when authorities request compliance. There are well known rights, such as the Miranda warning and the requirement for a warrant before entering a property, but search and seizure is a complex and hard to define topic with many details that people overlook. Under legal terms, blood is personal property. Police need a warrant or consent to take it.

While the nurse received attention for performing her job duties, the patient’s rights are central to this case. If the patient’s blood was drawn in these circumstances, it would likely be invalid evidence in court because it was taken without consent.

Upholding your rights

When interacting with police, it’s easy to feel intimidated by their authority. While most officers follow the rules, they are also humans who make mistakes on the job. If you have been arrested for a crime, it’s important to review the arrest procedure to make sure your rights are protected.

If you feel that your rights have been abused, it’s important that you speak with a criminal defense attorney to investigate your case as soon as possible. Police have a difficult job to maintain public safety, but the US Constitution provides a balance of power to make sure that your individual rights remain safe as well.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information
  • BBB Accredited Business
  • 10 Best 2016 Client Satisfaction American Institute Of Criminal Law Attorneys

Back To Top

Success Stories

  • Defendant was charged with sexual assault of a minor. At the deposition of the alleged victim, our firm got the alleged victim to confess that she made the whole thing up. Charges were dropped against our client.
  • Defendant was charged with possessing a large quantity of marijuana. Following a complete investigation by our firm, the State agreed to dismiss all charges against our client.
  • Defendant was charged with embezzling more than $300,000.00, from a previous employer. At the deposition of the alleged victim, our firm highlighted a number of inconsistencies and questionable statements. The State agreed to dismiss all charges against our client.
  • Defendant was charged with child abuse resulting in death. Following the investigation of our firm, depositions of key witnesses and presentation of our findings to the prosecutor, the State agreed to dismiss the charges against our client.
  • Defendant was charged with carrying a concealed weapon. The matter proceeded to trial and the jury found our client Not Guilty.

What Our Clients Say About Us

  • “Jim, Thank you for all of your help over the past couple weeks. I cannot emphasize enough how much better I have felt after receiving your help. Keeping my record clean as possible means a lot to me and I couldn’t have done it without you, thank you!” -TP
  • “Jim, It's always a pleasure to see you in court. Your effective, professional representation of your clients is so helpful.” -LW
  • “Jim, On behalf of the V family, please allow me to offer a HUGE thank you for your exemplary legal representation - especially considering you took on this case a mere 5 months ago. ” -CV
  • “Thank you so much Jim for everything you have been doing on my case, you are greatly appreciated. I will contact you if anything else comes up//until then God bless you! ” -SH
  • “Jim, thank you for everything. After I was resentenced I became eligible for camp custody. I am now on the RDAP list and doing fine” -MH
  • “JThank you so much for writing back. I read your response and I want you to know I completely trust you” -KV